John W. Chadwick, appellant, v. John Livesey, respondent

Per Curiam.

Decree affirmed, for the reasons given in the court of chancery.

For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Depue, Lippincott, Ludlow, Adams, Hendrickson, Nixon, Vredenburgh —8. For reversal-Collins, Dixon, Garrison, Van Syckel —4.