Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 2018

108 opinions

CONSOLIDATED INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant v. Christopher Lee SLONE; Jessica Cantrell; Nancy Perkins, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Raymond Mitchell Keeton, an Infant; Ramona Conley, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Samantha Conley, an Infant; Ramona Conley, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Kaylee Conley, an Infant; Crystal Hall, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Katilynn D. Hall, an Infant; Patricia Russell, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Tarah Russell, an Infant; Patricia Russell, as Mother, Natural Guardian, and Next Friend of Tatem Russell, an Infant; Heather Poe, as Parent and Natural Guardian of Rhylee Poe, an Infant; Bennie Poe, as Parent and Natural Guardian of Rhylee Poe, an Infant; David Blevins, as Grandfather, Custodian, and Next Friend of the Infant, Peyton Elkins; DeWayne Davis; Linda Howard ; Billie Ramey; Judy Francis, as Guardian and Next Friend of Kenna Isaac, an Infant; Sherri Arnett, as Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Christina Arnett, an Infant; Ashley Arnett, as Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Jacklyn Arnett, Madison Arnett, and Alexie Arnett, Infants; Shannon Vanhoose, as Natural Guardians and Next Friends of Linzie Vanhoose, an Infant; Jerry Vanhoose, as Natural Guardians and Next Friends of Linzie Vanhoose, an Infant; Duncan Vanhoose, an Infant; Clarissa Wells, as Natural Mother and Next Friend of Michael Wells, Matthew Wells and Jonathan Wells; Mandy Butcher, as Natural Mother and Next Friend of Laken Butcher, Jennie Butcher and Hannah Butcher; Alex Howard, By and Through His Next Friends, Ben Howard and Debbie Howard; Gunner Carty, By and Through His Next Friends, Garrett Ward and Wilma Ward; Ryan Gause, By and Through His Next Friend, Donna Daniels; Elsie Bailey, as Next Friend of Jeffrey Bailey ; Stacy Russell, as Next Friend of Erica and Destiny Russell; Katilynn D. Hall; Samantha Perkins, as Mother and Next Friend of Dominick Perkins and Dakota Perkins; Santana Allen, as Mother and Next Friend of Dakota Burchett and Jason Allen; Shawn Howard, By and Through His Natural Parent and Next Friend, Cathrine Cassady Howard; Joey Dotson; Kaylee Dotson; Kyle Casebolt; Michael Summers ; Jozie Dobbins; Megan Howard; James Meade; Jonbonet Stevens; Grover J. Allen; Lindsey B. Russell; Breanne Morrison, Through Her Father, James Morrison; Kayleigh Arnett, Through Her Mother, Virginia Murrell; Odell Pyles; GEICO General Insurance Company; Twin City Fire Insurance Company; Kemi ; Nationwide Property and Casualty Insurance Company; and Dwayne Davis, Appellees 2018-01-05
Charlie COLEMAN, John P. Roth Jr. and Erik Hermes, Appellants v. CAMPBELL COUNTY LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES, Appellee 2018-01-05
Ann D. QUATTROCCHI, Appellant/Cross-Appellee v. Paul NICHOLLS, M.D., Appellee/Cross-Appellant 2018-01-05
Donald STEFFAN, in His Individual Capacity as an Employee of the Jefferson County Board of Education and the Security Officer at Farnsley Middle School, Appellant v. Tevin SMYZER, BY AND THROUGH His Natural Parent and Next Friend, Tevis RANKINS, Appellee 2018-01-12
Matthew Brian DUFFY, Appellant/Cross-Appellee v. Faustina Lanet DUFFY, Appellee/Cross-Appellant 2018-01-19
J.L.C., Appellant v. CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and M.L.T., a Child, Appellees and J.L.C., Appellant v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and T.M.T., a Child, Appellees and J.L.C., Appellant v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and T.S.T., a Child, Appellees 2018-01-26
William COBLENTZ and Dorothy Coblentz, Appellants v. George DAY, Appellee 2018-01-26
David NEWMAN, Appellant v. ESTATE OF Joseph K. HOBBIC; Betty Hobbic, Co-Administratrix of the Joseph K. Hobbic Estate; and Deanna Mahoney, Co-Administratrix of the Joseph K. Hobbic Estate, Appellees 2018-02-02
James BENSON, Appellant v. Janet LIVELY, Appellee 2018-02-02
Michael J. SCANLON, Appellant v. Margaret T. SCANLON, Appellee 2018-02-02
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. Joseph CAMBRON, Appellee 2018-02-02
Tonya LINDSEY, Appellant v. BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF the UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY ; Tracey J. Eades; and Lisa Turner, Appellees 2018-02-02
Brent WASSON, Appellant v. KENTUCKY STATE POLICE, Appellee 2018-02-09
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. Ricky William FORD, Appellee 2018-02-09
Cassie Taulbee GENTRY, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Denton Cooper, Crystal Mays and Sheena Reece, Appellants v. Kimberly Savage NOE, Individually and in her Official Capacity as Deputy Clerk/Clerk of Lee County, Kentucky, Appellee 2018-02-09
Jeffrey JARBOE, Appellant v. Doreen REYNOLDS, Appellee 2018-02-16
Brett BAILEY, Appellant v. KENTUCKY LOTTERY CORPORATION, Appellee 2018-02-16
John CHERRY, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-02-16
Janet FRALEY, Appellant v. Phillip ZAMBOS, M.D.; and Eastern Kentucky Imaging, P.S.C., Appellees 2018-02-16
Patrick HARDY, Appellant v. David BEACH, Appellee 2018-02-16
Clyde Douglas MAYS, Appellant v. Melissa Ann MAYS, Appellee 2018-02-23
Garfield Donte EVANS, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-02-23
Blaire PHILLIPS, Appellant v. Hon. Anne DELAHANTY and Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellees 2018-02-23
Michael Thomas GOODLETT, Appellant/Cross-Appellee v. Bill BRITTAIN; and Marsha Brittain, Appellees/Cross-Appellants and Michael Thomas Goodlett, Appellant v. Marsha Brittain; and Bill Brittain, Appellees 2018-02-23
Will HARROD, Individually and Will Harrod, in his Official Capacity as Franklin County Coroner, Appellant v. Kathleen CANEY, Appellee 2018-02-23
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. Hon. Diane WHEELER, Judge, Oldham District Court; and Paul Brady, Appellees 2018-02-23
ESTATE OF Geneva ADAMS, BY AND THROUGH Her Personal Representative, Sharon MITCHELL, Appellant v. Dr. Phillip TROVER and The Trover Clinic Foundation, Inc. d/b/a Baptist Health Madisonville, Inc., Appellees 2018-03-02
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, FINANCE and Administration Cabinet, Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellant v. REVELATION ENERGY, LLC, Appellee 2018-03-09
Charles E. MOORE and Jana P. Moore, Trustees Under the Charles E. Moore and Jana P. Moore Revocable Living Trust Dated April 1, 2008, Appellants v. CORBIN BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT; Corbin Planning Commission; The City of Corbin; Melinda S. Norvell; and James D. Norvell, Jr., Appellees 2018-03-09
JACKSON HOSPITAL CORPORATION d/b/a Kentucky River Medical Center, Appellant v. UNITED CLINICS OF KENTUCKY, LLC, Appellee 2018-03-09
Marc Irwin COBANE, Appellant v. Laurie Lynn COBANE, Appellee 2018-03-23
Alicia RITCHIE and Jane Doe, Appellants v. Arch TURNER; David Napier; Michael Bowling; Reggie Hamilton; Charles Mitchell; Kentucky Department of Insurance; and Kentucky School Board Insurance Trust, Appellees 2018-03-23
Randy WOODS, Appellant v. PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS & COUNTER-INTELLIGENCE, INC.; Hon. Jonathan R. Weatherby, Administrative Law Judge; and Workers Compensation Board, Appellees 2018-03-30
KENTUCKY RETIREMENT SYSTEMS, Appellant v. Bret CHAMBERLAIN, Appellee 2018-03-30
CITY OF RICHMOND, Richmond Planning and Zoning Commission, and David Rush, Chairman of the Richmond Planning and Zoning Commission, Appellants v. SPANGLER APARTMENTS, LLC; and Meridian Partners, LLC, Appellees 2018-04-06
Charles William PEARSON, Appellant v. Paula PEARSON and Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company, Appellees 2018-04-06
Kimberly Ann HILLARD, Appellant v. Jerry Lance KEATING, Appellee 2018-04-13
Marissa Kaylene DUNN, Appellant v. Ryan Chase THACKER, Appellee 2018-04-13
Omar MATEHUALA, Appellant v. Jeanetta Louann Matehuala TORRES, Appellee 2018-04-13
Mary Blanche GADDIE, Appellant v. Raymond J. BENAITIS and Viola Benaitis, Appellees 2018-04-27
Cedric GRADY, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-04-27
James Gerald EMBRY, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-04-27
CLK MULTIFAMILY MANAGEMENT, LLC, Appellant v. GREENSCAPES LAWN & LANDSCAPING, INC., and Jane Hermes, Appellees 2018-04-27
NEW MEADOWVIEW HEALTH AND REHABILITATION CENTER, LLC, d/b/a Meadowview Health and Rehabilitation Center; Senior Care US Holdings, Inc.; and Elmcroft Senior Living, Inc., d/b/a Elmcroft Senior Living, Appellants v. Monica L. BOOKER, as Administratrix of the Estate of Mona Hardin; and William Hardin, Individually, Appellees 2018-05-04
Khristina LARISON, Appellant v. HOME OF THE INNOCENTS, Appellees 2018-05-11
Edgar A. STOWE, d/b/a Eds Auto, Appellant v. REALCO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, Appellee 2018-05-11
Larry HARMS and Pamela Harms, Appellants v. CHASE HOME FINANCE, LLC; Ethel Grace Smith; Richard Cheek; Karen Cheek ; National City Bank; Jamos Fund I, LP ; DOT Capital Investments, LLC; and Mid South Capital Partners, LP, Appellees 2018-05-11
Kathyrn Michelle HAWKINS, Appellant v. Joshua JONES, Appellee 2018-05-11
Rona ALEXANDER, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-05-11
Kibrom ZEWOLDI, Appellant v. TRANSIT AUTHORITY OF RIVER CITY and Carolyn Bryant, Appellees 2018-05-18
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. Julia A. BROWN, Appellee 2018-05-18
Hon. Sean R. DELAHANTY, in His Official Capacity as Jefferson District Court Judge; and Hon. Stephanie Pearce Burke, in Her Official Capacity as Jefferson District Court Judge, Appellants v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-05-25
Jeanette JONES, Appellant v. David Samuel LIVESAY, Appellee 2018-06-01
WPSD TV, The Paducah Sun, and the Marshall County Tribune-Courier, Petitioners v. Honorable James T. JAMESON, Judge, Marshall Circuit Court, Respondent and Gabriel Ross Parker, and Commonwealth of Kentucky, Real Parties in Interest 2018-06-01
James Guy CARR, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-06-01
Miles Devon SKEENS, Appellant v. UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE, Appellee 2018-06-01
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. Steven RODEN, Appellee 2018-06-01
KUCHLE REALTY COMPANY, LLC, Appellant v. The COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Transportation Cabinet, Department of Highways; Anchor Kentucky Partners, LLC; Walgreen Company; and Nationwide Bank, FSB, Appellees 2018-06-01
Jonathan Tyler SYKES, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-06-08
WESTERN SURETY COMPANY, Appellant v. CITY OF NICHOLASVILLE, Kentucky ; Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District; Jessamine County Water District No. 1 ; Jessamine County Fiscal Court; and Jessamine County-City of Wilmore Joint Planning Commission, Appellees 2018-06-08
ESTATE OF Ubong DAVID, Appellant v. Darren POUNDS and Rick Pounds, Appellees Estate of Ubong David, Appellant v. Samuel Boone, Appellee 2018-06-15
Heidi Jill OFFICER, Appellant v. Roger Lee BLANKENSHIP, Appellee 2018-06-15
COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellant v. William BENNETT, Appellee 2018-06-22
Sean HUMBER, Dominico Morbley, Aaron Ruffin, Gregory Stokes, Kem Anderson and Tim Anderson, Individually and Through Their Guardians, Appellants v. LEXINGTON-FAYETTE URBAN COUNTY GOVERNMENT, Appellee 2018-06-29
J.E., A.B., and M.E., Appellants v. CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY SERVICES, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and A.N.E., a Minor Child, Appellees and J.E., A.B., and M.E., Appellants v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and A.E., a Minor Child, Appellees and J.E., A.B., and M.E., Appellants v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, Commonwealth of Kentucky; and Z.E., a Minor Child, Appellees 2018-06-29
R.J. PALMER, II and The Fund To Re-Elect Senator R.J. Palmer, Appellants v. Ralph ALVARADO, Appellee 2018-06-29
Travis WILSON, Appellant v. Staci INGLIS, Appellee 2018-07-06
Peyton FELTNER, as Administrator of the Estate of Earl Bransford Feltner, Appellant v. PJ OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a Papa Johns Kentucky, and PJ Holdings KY, LLC; Papa Johns International, Inc.; and Toney Jones, Appellees and Peyton Feltner, as Administrator of the Estate of Earl Bransford Feltner, Appellant v. PJ Operations, LLC d/b/a Papa Johns Kentucky, and PJ Holdings KY, LLC; Toney Jones; and Papa Johns International, Inc., Appellees 2018-07-06
Evan Matthew FRY, Appellant v. April Dawn CAUDILL, Appellee 2018-07-13
Ruben Rios SALINAS, Appellant v. CORRECT CARE SOLUTIONS, LLC, Appellee 2018-07-13
Devante A. MARKS, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-07-27
Jolie C. KEITH, Appellant v. Toby N. KEITH, Appellee 2018-07-27
Steven F. LIPSON, M.D., Appellant v. UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE and University Medical Center, Inc., Appellees 2018-07-27
C.S., a Minor Child, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-07-27
The CITY OF NICHOLASVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT and Melissa Rhoads, Administratrix of the Estate of Burke Rhoads, Appellants v. Sean ABRAHAM; Nisreen Abraham; Zianna Abraham; and Chasity Gordon, Appellees 2018-07-27
Menelik BRANK, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-07-27
George Samuel FULTZ, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-08-03
Bruce CALDWELL, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-08-03
Larri FLEGE, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-08-03
David William Claude ROBINSON, Appellant v. Jana Hughes ROBINSON, Appellee 2018-08-03
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE, INC. and James Michael Mattingly, Appellants v. William BARBER, Jeffery Goree, Curtis Weathers, Glenn Jackson, Lamont Brown, Donald Ragland, John Hughes and David Young, D. Luke Morgan, Stephen G. Amato, and David J. Guarneri, Appellees 2018-08-10
Marc HARDIN, Appellant v. The JEFFERSON COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION d/b/a Jefferson County Public Schools; Dr. Donna M. Hargens, Superintendent; Dr. Michael Raisor, Chief Operations Officer; Diane L. Porter, Chair, District 1; Debbie Wesslund, District 3; David A. Jones, Jr., District 2; Chuck Haddaway, District 4; Linda Duncan, District 5; Carol Ann Haddad, District 6 and Chris Brady, District 7, Appellees 2018-08-10
Michael MULLINS, Appellant v. RURAL METRO CORP.; Hon. Udell Levy, Administrative Law Judge; and Workers Compensation Board, Appellees and Rural Metro Corp., Cross-Appellant v. Michael Mullins; Hon. Udell Levy, Administrative Law Judge; and Workers Compensation Board, Cross-Appellees 2018-08-10
Aaron CAMPBELL, Appellant v. Rodney BALLARD, Commissioner, Kentucky Department of Corrections, Appellee 2018-08-17
Robert F. GROSSL, Adam T. Zornes, Anne Northcutt, Richard Ledoux, Jr., Joe Stamper, and Fred Thomas Williamson, Appellant v. SCOTT COUNTY FISCAL COURT, Appellee 2018-08-17
SMITHFIELD FARMS, LLC, Appellant v. RIVERSIDE DEVELOPERS, LLC, Appellee 2018-08-17
Cherie JABURG, Appellant v. John Scott JABURG, Appellee 2018-08-24
Mary Clair KRIETEMEYER, Appellant v. CITY OF MADISONVILLE, Kentucky ; and Madisonville Police Department, Appellees 2018-08-24
Anthony Terrell MARTIN, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-09-07
Jason CONLEY, Appellant v. SUPER SERVICES, LLC; Hon. Monica Rice-Smith, Administrative Law Judge; and Workers Compensation Board, Appellees 2018-09-07
Helen Louise MARSHALL and Martha Wilke, Appellants v. Martha Dianne MARSHALL, Appellee 2018-09-07
Ora WALKER, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-09-07
Christopher APPLEGATE, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee and Christopher Applegate, Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellee and Christopher Applegate, Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellee and Christopher Applegate, Appellant v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-09-14
UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY, Appellant v. LEXINGTON H-L SERVICES, INC., d/b/a Lexington Herald-Leader, Appellee 2018-09-14
Bradley CLARK, Appellant v. Tonya PARRETT, Appellee 2018-09-21
Steve MIRACLE, in His Official Capacity as Superintendent of the Trimble County Schools; and the Board of Education of Trimble County, Appellants v. Tammy DUNCAN; Stephen L. Pruitt, Ph.D., in His Official Capacity as the Commissioner of Education; and Andrew Beshear, Attorney General, Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appellees 2018-09-21
Trenton ADAMS, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-09-28
C.F., Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-10-05
Dustin THURMAN, Appellant v. Jennifer THURMAN, Appellee 2018-10-12
Ashley CURTY, Appellant v. NORTON HEALTHCARE, INC., Appellee 2018-10-12
Behram TAVADIA and Tavadia Enterprises, Inc., Appellants v. Sheri A. MITCHELL, Appellee 2018-10-19
Kenneth ALFORD, Appellant v. KENTUCKY UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE COMMISSION; and Ohio County Board of Education, Appellees 2018-10-19
Dan HOWARD and Sherolyn Howard, Appellants v. Leslie Matthew SPRADLIN, Appellee 2018-10-26
Tyree YOPP, Appellant v. COMMONWEALTH of Kentucky, Appellee 2018-10-26
Brandy Jadell HAMILTON, Appellant v. Robert DUVALL ; Sharon Duvall; and Joshua Edmond Duvall, Father, Now Deceased, Appellees 2018-10-26
Michael SIDEBOTTOM, Appellant v. WATERSHED EQUINE, LLC, Appellee 2018-10-26
Alicia L. PETERSON, Appellant v. GRANGE PROPERTY & CASUALTY, Appellee 2018-10-26
Darla DELLAPENTA, Appellant v. Brandon GOLDY, Appellee 2018-10-26