Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals, 2016

50 opinions

The STATE of Oklahoma ex rel. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, Plaintiff/Appellant/Counter-Appellee, v. CALIBER DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC, Defendant/Appellee/Counter-Appellant The Oklahoma County Treasurer, Defendant 2016-01-05
Brandon Chase RYAN, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. COMMISSIONER OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY, State of Oklahoma, Defendant/Appellee, 2016-01-15
Eric SAMPLE, Plaintiff/appellee, v. STATE of Oklahoma, EX REL. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY, Defendant/appellant 2016-01-29
Janice STEIDLEY, David Iski, and Sean McConnell, Plaintiffs/appellees, v. COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER HOLDINGS, INC., Newspaper Holdings, Inc., Bailey Dabney, Randy Cowling, and Salesha Wilken, Defendants/appellants 2016-01-29
ARK WRECKING COMPANY OF OKLAHOMA, INC., Plaintiff/Appellant, v. VARGAS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC., Defendant and Third-Party Plaintiff, v. Independent School District Number One of Tulsa County, Oklahoma, aka Tulsa Public Schools, Defendant and Third-Party Defendant/Appellee 2016-02-05
In re the Marriage of: Patricia JOHNSON, Petitioner/Appellee, v. Lee JOHNSON, Respondent/Appellant 2016-02-12
STATE OF OKLAHOMA EX REL., John D. DOAK, Insurance Commissioner, Petitioner/Appellee, v. PRIDE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant, Fifth Third Bank, Appellant 2016-02-12
TINKER FEDERAL CREDIT UNION, Plaintiff, v. Nancy Lynn JOHNSON, Defendant/Appellee, and Connie Sue Henthorn, Defendant/Appellant 2016-02-18
In the Matter of the AIRCRAFT EXCISE TAX PROTEST OF BMB AIRCRAFT, LLC. BMB Aircraft, LLC, Appellant, v. Oklahoma Tax Commission, Appellee 2016-02-18
Bruce E. NIEMI, Eddie L. Evans, Donald A. Lowe, and Doris M. Orr, Plaintiffs/ Appellants, v. CITY OF TULSA, a Municipal Corporation, Defendant/Appellee 2016-02-19
BANK OF OKLAHOMA, N.A., a national bank, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. David Wayne MILLER II and Heather Leigh Miller, Defendants/Appellants, and Chateau MMH, Inc.; Mers as Nominee for E Loan; Cockrell Trust; Dij, Inc.; Leaf Funding; Marlin Leasing Corp.; Bank of America, NA; David Younce; Bank of Oklahoma, N.A. (Mortgage Division), Defendants 2016-02-25
The PHOENIX GROUP HOLDING COMPANY, Appellant, v. STATE of Oklahoma, ex rel. OKLAHOMA CORPORATION COMMISSION, a state agency; and Commissioners Patrice Douglas, Bob Anthony, and Dana L. Murphy, Appellees 2016-03-02
In the Matter of the ADOPTION OF B.T.S., a Minor Child, Tamera N. Smith, Appellant, v. Teresa Nixon and Quahana Nixon, Appellees 2016-03-07
Robert Judson RADFORD, Petitioner/Appellant, v. Melissa Jennings RADFORD, Respondent/Appellee 2016-03-11
Kenneth E. SOULE, Petitioner, v. CRANE LOGISTICS &/or James Crane &/or Crane Cartage Freight Systems &/or William & Barbara OConnell &/or Ashton Leasing and the Workers Compensation Court of Existing Claims, Respondents, and Wildcat Freight Inc., Respondent, and Unknown or not Specified &/or Travelers Indemnity Co. of Connecticut &/or No Insurance, Insurance Carrier 2016-03-11
Roger DAVIS, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. The OKLAHOMA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and Robert Patton, as director, Defendants/Appellees 2016-03-14
In the Matter of the ADOPTION OF K.L.C., a Minor Child. Timothy James Metrovich, Petitioner/Appellant, v. Vincent Lee Coughran, Respondent/Appellee 2016-03-18
Sherrine Lynn OBRIEN, Petitioner/Appellee, v. Chris Allen BERRY, Defendant/Appellant 2016-03-28
WELLS FARGO BANK, National Association, Plaintiff/appellee, v. APACHE TRIBE OF OKLAHOMA, Defendant/appellant 2016-03-28
Floyd MANAR and Margie M. Manar, pellees/Counter-Appellants, v. James H. WESSON and Jamie Wesson, Defendants/Counter-Claimants/Appellants/Counter-Appellees 2016-04-08
Teresa SAUDERS and Michael Lowell, Individuals and Next of Kin of Betty Lowell, Deceased, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. MANGUM NURSING CENTER, LLC, d/b/a Grace Living Center-Mangum; Don Greiner, Individually; Amity Care, LLC, Defendants/Appellees 2016-04-11
Brenda G. WEAVER, as Power of Attorney of Virginia Quay Weaver, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. John DOE, individually, and John Doe, as Agent of Peak Medical Oklahoma No. 3, Inc., d/b/a Forest Hills Care and Rehabilitation Center, Defendants/Appellants 2016-04-11
Michael GRINDSTAFF and Debbie Grindstaff, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. The OAKS OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., Defendant/Appellee 2016-04-25
Jeromy MURANO, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Heather JACOBS, David Crowley, Daniel Crowley and Julie E. Wagoner, Defendants/Appellees 2016-04-26
Joe MEDDERS and Joe Miller, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. Christopher YOUNG, Defendant/Appellee 2016-04-26
Thomas FOX, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Tim FOX, Charles A. Dickson, III; and Charles A. Dickson, III PLLC, Defendants/Appellees 2016-04-29
Timothy LEWIS and Nancy Lewis, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. DUST BOWL TULSA, LLC, Defendant/Appellee 2016-05-02
The MARGARET BLAIR TRUST, a Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd.; Margaret A. Blair, an individual and beneficiary of the Margaret Blair Trust; The Patricia Jane Bender Trust, a Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd.; Patricia Jane Bender, an individual and beneficiary of the Patricia Jane Bender Trust; The Mary Alice Blair Trust, a Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd.; and Mary Alice Blair, an individual and beneficiary of the Mary Alice Blair Trust, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. Robert G. BLAIR, individually, as beneficiary of the Robert G. Blair Trust, as Trustee under Last Will and Testament of W.W. Blair, deceased, as Trustee of each Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd., as General Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd. and as an officer, Director and owner of Comanche Exploration Co. LLC, and Comanche Resources Company; The Robert G. Blair Trust, a Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd.; Comanche Exploration Co. LLC; Comanche Resources Company; The John David Blair Trust, a Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd.; JOHN DAVID BLAIR, individually, as beneficiary of the John David Blair Trust, as Trustee under Last Will and Testament of W.W. Blair, deceased, as Trustee of each Limited Partner of Blair Royalties, Ltd. and as an officer, Employee and owner of Comanche Exploration Co. LLC, and Comanche Resources Company; and Blair Royalties, Ltd., Defendants/Appellees 2016-05-13
In the MATTER OF the Assessment for Tax Year 2011 of Certain Personal Property Owned by MISSOURI GAS ENERGY, a Division of Southern Union Company: Missouri Gas Energy, a Division of Southern Union Company, Appellant, v. Grant County Assessor and Grant County Board of Equalization, Appellees 2016-05-13
Ariel NUNCIO, individually and as father and next friend of Sherel Nuncio, a minor, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. ROCK KNOLL TOWNHOME VILLAGE, INC., an Oklahoma corporation; Bill McGraw, individually and as President of Rock Knoll Townhome Village, Inc.; Ronald Plato; John Plato; Moriah Plato; Mildred Plato; and Does 1-10, Defendants/Appellees 2016-05-13
In the MATTER OF the ESTATE OF B. Gail STARNES, Deceased. Christina Guerra, Appellant, v. Kent A. Starnes and G. Scott Starnes, Appellees 2016-05-24
Robert D. NIX, Petitioner, v. FIRST STAFFING GROUP USA, Compsource Mutual Ins. and the Workers Compensation Commission, Respondents 2016-06-03
IN RE the MARRIAGE OF M. PATRICK and A. Patrick: M. Patrick, Petitioner/Appellee, v. A. Patrick, Respondent/Appellant 2016-06-16
Charles DEAL and Annette Deal, Personal Representatives of the Estate of Serenity Deal, Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. Sean Devon BROOKS, Randy J. Lack, and Jennifer Shawn, Defendants, and State of Oklahoma ex rel. Oklahoma Department of Human Services, Defendant/appellee 2016-06-24
Aaron Lee BENSHOOF, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Jerry NILES and [John] Marcus, Defendants/Appellees, and Garfield County Commissioners, Sheriff Dept., and Detention Center, Defendants 2016-07-19
Orlando R. FERNANDEZ, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. STATE of Oklahoma ex rel., Department of Public Safety, Defendant/Appellant 2016-07-29
Marilyn L. MORTON, Plaintiff, v. Nancy H. WATSON, Defendant; and Tulsa Spine and Specialty Hospital, Hospital Lien Claimant/appellee, v. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, Subrogation Lien Claimant/appellant 2016-07-29
DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPANY, as Trustee for the Certificate Holders of the Morgan Stanley ABS Capital 1 Inc. Trust 2006-NC5, Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2006 NC-5, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. Sherri D. MYERS and Carey Mark Baca, Defendants/Appellants, and John Doe; Jane Doe; Steven D. Lester; Karen Lester and New Century Mortgage Corporation, Additional Defendants 2016-08-03
Joshua SHAW, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. CITY OF OKLAHOMA CITY, Defendant/Appellee 2016-08-11
TINKER FEDERAL CREDIT UNION, Plaintiff, v. Jimmy D. GRANT, Defendant/Appellant, Bishop L. Berryhill and Camden L. Berryhill, Defendants/Appellees, and Kenneth Boulware, Sheila Mosley-Boulware and Suzann M. Grant, Defendants 2016-08-16
Christopher JOHNSTON, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. James STACY, Defendant/Appellee 2016-08-18
IN RE the MARRIAGE OF Roy Paul DORSEY and Betty Lillian, Dorsey: Roy Paul Dorsey, Petitioner/Appellant, v. Betty Lillian Dorsey, Respondent/Appellee 2016-08-25
Rufus VANCE and Glenda Robertson, Plaintiffs/Appellees, v. ENOGEX GAS GATHERING, L.L.C., an Oklahoma Corporation, Defendant/Appellant 2016-08-26
Jason Oliver STAUFF, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Roy and Kimberly BARTNICK, Individuals, and Paramount Homes Real Estate Co., an Oklahoma Corporation, Defendants/Appellees, and Stuart Benge, d/b/a Stu Benge Plb. Htg. AC, and Greg Palmer Electric, LLC, an Oklahoma Limited Liability Company, Defendants 2016-09-02
OSAGE ENERGY RESOURCES, LLC, Plaintiff/Appellee, v. PEMCO, LLC, and Richard Coody, Defendants/Appellants 2016-09-09
Kurtis D. REED, Petitioner/Appellee, v. Elizabeth A. REMMERT, Respondent/Appellant 2016-09-19
DIANE CARISTA, as surviving sister and next of kin, and on behalf of herself and all other heirs-at-law to Barton Ray Carista, decedent, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. WILLIAM M. VALUCK, D.O.; MICHAEL E. HUME, P.A.; DOROTHY JUNE HUME; PATRICK REYNOLDS; GOOD TO GO, LLC, dba VISTA MEDICAL CENTER and ADVANCED CARE CLINIC, LLC, Defendants, and WESTMINSTER FAMILY DRUG, Defendant/Appellee 2016-09-19
In the MATTER OF the Application of DOBSON TELEPHONE COMPANY d/b/a McLoud Telephone Company for Funding From the Oklahoma Universal Service Fund, Dobson Telephone Company d/b/a McLoud Telephone Company, Appellant, v. State of Oklahoma ex rel. Oklahoma Corporation Commission, Appellee 2016-09-22
HOUGH OILFIELD SERVICE, INC., d/b/a Hotco, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Randall NEWTON and Linda Newton, Defendants/Appellees 2016-09-22
Jack SHAFFER, Petitioner/Appellant, v. CITY OF MUSKOGEE MERIT SYSTEM BOARD and City of Muskogee, Oklahoma, a Municipal Corporation, Respodents/appellees 2016-09-23