United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, 2009

141 opinions

HAEMONETICS CORP., Plaintiff, v. BAXTER HEALTHCARE CORP. and Fenwal, Inc., Defendants 2009-01-05
Sagun TULI, M.D., Plaintiff, v. BRIGHAM & WOMENS HOSPITAL, INC., and Arthur Day, M.D., Defendants 2009-01-06
Bradley Ward BEAN, Plaintiff, v. GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, Defendant 2009-01-06
Blanca BAEZ, Plaintiff v. Michael J. ASTRUE, Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant 2009-01-06
HAEMONETICS CORP., Plaintiff, v. BAXTER HEALTHCARE CORP. and Fenwal, Inc., Defendants 2009-01-07
The SOUTHERN NEW ENGLAND TELEPHONE COMPANY, Plaintiff, v. GLOBAL NAPS, INC., Global Naps New Hampshire, Inc., Global Naps Networks, Inc., Global Naps Realty, Inc. and Ferrous Miner Holdings, Ltd., Defendants. Convergent Networks, Inc. and Frank T. Gangi, Reach and Apply, Defendants 2009-01-07
UNITED STATES of America, v. Frank IACABONI, Defendant 2009-01-08
In re AMERICAN BRIDGE PRODUCTS, INC., Debtor. Lynne F. Riley, Chapter 7 Trustee of American Bridge Products, Inc., Plaintiff-Appellee v. Nicholas J. Decoulos, Esq. and Decoulos & Decoulos, Defendants-Appellants 2009-01-08
VERTEX SURGICAL, INC., Plaintiff, v. PARADIGM BIODEVICES, INC., Defendant 2009-01-09
UNITED STATES of America, v. Joseph SILVA, Defendant 2009-01-09
Brian KENNEDY and Michelle Kennedy, Individually and as mother and next friend of Mitchell Kennedy and Dylan Kennedy, Brian Kennedy, Jr., William Ashton, Plaintiffs, v. TOWN OF BILLERICA, Daniel C. Rosa, Jr., Individually and as Chief of the Billerica Police Department, Andrew DeVito, William G. West, Sgt. Roy Frost, Steven Elmore, John Herring, John Doe, John Roe, Defendants 2009-01-12
Jonathan KLAUCKE, Plaintiff v. Brian C. DALY, Defendant 2009-01-13
ROSIE D., by her parents JOHN and Debra D., et al., Plaintiffs v. Deval PATRICK, et al., Defendants 2009-01-14
CAPITOL RECORDS, INC., et al., Plaintiffs, v. Noor ALAUJAN, Defendant; Sony BMG Music Entertainment, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Joel Tenenbaum, Defendant 2009-01-14
Murray GINTIS, Victoria Gintis, and Claudia Martin, Individually and as Representatives of a Proposed Class, Plaintiffs, v. BOUCHARD TRANSPORTATION COMPANY, INC., Tug Evening Tide Corporation, and B. No. 120 Corporation, Defendants 2009-01-15
Thomas STEFANIK, Plaintiff v. CITY OF HOLYOKE, et al., Shawn Willis, et al., City of Holyoke, et al., Defendants 2009-01-20
Cathy CURRAN, Juarez De Souza Barboza, Ronald Day and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs v. FEDEX GROUND PACKAGE SYSTEM, INC., and Fedex Ground Package System, Inc. d/b/a Fedex Home Delivery, Defendants 2009-01-21
UNITED STATES of America v. Darwin JONES, Defendant 2009-01-21
Scott SPOTTISWOODE v. Scott SON 2009-01-23
Michael B. ELGIN, Aaron Lawson, Henry Tucker and Christon Colby on behalf of themselves and similarly situated men throughout the United States, Plaintiffs, v. UNITED STATES of America, United States Department of the Treasury, and United States Department of the Interior, Defendants 2009-01-26
UNITED STATES of America, v. Arthur GIANELLI, Mary Ann Gianelli, Frank Iacoboni, Dennis Albertelli, Randy Albertelli, Gisele Albertelli, Rafia Feghi, and Joseph Yerardi, Defendants 2009-01-26
Commonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS by its DIVISION OF MARINE FISHERIES, and State of New Hampshire, by its Fish & Game Department, Division of Marine Fisheries, Plaintiffs v. Carlos M. GUTIERREZ, in his official capacity as Secretary of Commerce of the United States, et al., Defendants 2009-01-26
APPLERA CORPORATION, Plaintiff v. MICHIGAN DIAGNOSTICS, LLC, Defendant 2009-01-27
UNITED STATES of America, v. Demone COLEMAN, Defendant 2009-01-29
Richard Max STRAHAN, Plaintiff, v. Daniel HOLMES, Defendant 2009-01-30
UNITED STATES of America v. John T. FOLEY and Patricia Meshna Foley 2009-02-03
Jean Walensky OSCAR, Petitioner, v. Brian GILLEN, Respondent 2009-02-03
Marek BORKOWSKI, Rufus Alfred Ayers, and Steven Wood, Plaintiffs, v. F/V MADISON KATE and F/V Holdings, Inc. d/b/a Sea Ventures, LLC, Defendants 2009-02-06
Cecil BARRETT, Jr., Cynthia Barrett, Jean Blanco Guerrier, Angelique M. Bastien, Jacqueline Grissett, Craig Grissett, and Steven Parham on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated v. H & R BLOCK, INC., Option One Mortgage Corporation and H & R Block Mortgage Corporation n/k/a Option One Mortgage Services, Inc. 2009-02-06
In the Matter of the COMPLAINT OF Philip R. MARTIN, Petitioner, As Owner of the 42 1989 Chris Craft, 427 Catalina Double Cabin, Pleasure Vessel, Tranquility, USCG Doc. No. 1109120, For Exoneration from or Limitation of Liability 2009-02-09
Luis RIVERA v. David NOLAN 2009-02-09
Allan and Donna BONNEY, Plaintiffs v. WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK, as Successor in Interest to Long Beach Mortgage Company, Defendant 2009-02-09
Carlos LOPEZ and Ondina E. Benitez v. EQUITY OFFICE MANAGEMENT, LLC 2009-02-10
Kristin DASILVA-SANTOS, Plaintiff v. Michel J. ASTRUE, as the Commissioner, Social Security Administration, Defendant 2009-02-10
John FORTUNATO, Plaintiff v. COOLEY DICKINSON HOSPITAL, INC., Defendant 2009-02-11
Deepak JAHAGIRDAR, Petitioner, v. UNITED STATES of America, Respondent 2009-02-11
Edward SMITH, Plaintiff, v. BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF MASSACHUSETTS, INC., Defendant 2009-02-12
Kirk DAHL, et al., Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs v. BAIN CAPITAL PARTNERS, LLC, et al., Defendants 2009-02-12
UNITED STATES of America v. Jeffrey SHIELDS, Respondent 2009-02-12
Jeremy MORIN, Petitioner, v. Commonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS, Respondent 2009-02-20
Jordan M. RICE, Plaintiff, v. Eugene P. McCANN, Defendant 2009-02-20
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, Plaintiff, v. Steven E. NOTHERN, Defendant 2009-02-20
Dr. Julie COLBY, Plaintiff v. ASSURANT EMPLOYEE BENEFITS, Fortis Benefits Insurance Company, Management Company for Merrimack Anesthesia Associates Long Term Disability Plan, and Union Security Insurance Company and Management Company for Merrimack Anesthesia Associates Long Term Disability Plan, Defendants 2009-02-23
Commonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS by its DIVISION OF MARINE FISHERIES, and State of New Hampshire, by its Fish & Game Department, Division of Marine Fisheries, Plaintiffs v. Carlos M. GUTIERREZ, in his official capacity as Secretary of Commerce of the United States, et al., Defendants 2009-02-23
UNITED STATES of America, ex rel. Patrick J. LOUGHREN, Plaintiff, v. UNUMPROVIDENT CORP., et al., Defendants 2009-02-24
Nicholas ESTEVEZ, Petitioner, v. UNITED STATES of America, Respondent 2009-02-26
JENKINS STARR, LLC and Ruth Jenkins, Plaintiffs, v. CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY, INC., Defendant 2009-02-26
UNITED STATES of America, Petitioner v. John Charles VOLUNGUS, Respondent 2009-02-27
ROSIE D., et al., Plaintiffs v. Deval L. PATRICK, et al., Defendants 2009-02-27
VICOR CORPORATION, Plaintiff, v. VIGILANT INSURANCE COMPANY, Federal Insurance Company and Continental Casualty Company, Defendants 2009-03-02
DEMERS BROS. TRUCKING, INC. and Mossberg Realty Corporation, Plaintiffs, v. CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS, LONDON, SUBSCRIBING TO CERTIFICATE NUMBER SRS IM MA 04-124, Defendant 2009-03-03
Tim McGUIGAN, Plaintiff, v. John CONTE and Joseph Early, District Attorney of Worcester, Defendants 2009-03-04
AVX CORPORATION and AVX Limited v. CABOT CORPORATION 2009-03-05
Nathan TYLER, Daniel ONeil and Carlos Marquez, Plaintiffs, v. SUFFOLK COUNTY, Andrea J. Cabral and Gerard Horgan, Defendants 2009-03-05
Eduard SHENKER, Plaintiff, v. The CITY OF LAWRENCE, Defendant 2009-03-06
Robert PLUMMER v. TOWN OF SOMERSET, Joseph C. Ferreira, International Brotherhood of Police Officers Local 518, and Michael Williams 2009-03-09
UNITED STATES of America ex rel. Kerry DEERING, Plaintiff, v. PHYSIOTHERAPY ASSOCIATES, INC., Stryker Corporation, and John Does 1-8, Defendants 2009-03-10
In re BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION SECURITIES LITIGATION 2009-03-10
Daniel CROWL, Plaintiff, v. M. CHIN REALTY TRUST, Defendant 2009-03-10
Charles D. FOLEY, Jr., Plaintiff, v. TOWN OF RANDOLPH, Richard W. Wells, in his official capacity, Paul J. Connors, in his official capacity, William Alexopoulos, in his official capacity, Maureen C. Kenny, in her individual and official capacities, James F. Burgess, Jr., in his individual and official capacities, Defendants 2009-03-11
Jessica C. RULE, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. FORT DODGE ANIMAL HEALTH, INC., and Wyeth Corporation, Defendants 2009-03-11
Ronald J. KOGUT, Petitioner v. Michael J. ASHE, Jr., Respondent 2009-03-11
David W. EISENBERG, Plaintiff, v. Edmund F. WALL, Eugene Terry McSweeney, Edward J. Weiner, Karen L. Springer, Scott Carpenter, Margery R. McDonald, Andy Ungerson, Lee Callahan, Lawrence R. Rittenberg, Catherine E. Read, James J. Dion, Steven Yetman, Sharon Walker Mastenbrook, Heidi L. Porter, Town of Burlington Board of Health and Town of Burlington, Defendants 2009-03-12
Greg T. SCHUBERT, Plaintiff v. CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, et al, Defendants 2009-03-12
Randy K. SILVA, Plaintiff, v. Harold W. CLARKE, Donna Jurdak and UMass Correctional Healthcare, Defendants 2009-03-13
AWARE, INC., Plaintiff, v. CENTILLIUM COMMUNICATIONS, INC., Defendant 2009-03-13
Kenneth R. MITCHELL and Charlene M. Giantommaso, On behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. GLOBE NEWSPAPER COMPANY, INC., Defendant 2009-03-13
David W. LAUGHTON, et al., Plaintiffs, v. CGI TECHNOLOGIES AND SOLUTIONS, INC., Defendant 2009-03-13
Daniel AVERY, Plaintiff v. Michael J. ASTRUE, Commissioner, Social Security Administration, Defendant 2009-03-13
UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff v. Maria MARQUEZ, Sarah Supernaw, Smileen Matos, Isaac Torres, and John Harley, Defendants 2009-03-17
NEW ENGLAND CARPENTERS HEALTH BENEFITS FUND, et al., Plaintiffs, v. FIRST DATABANK, INC. and McKesson Corporation, Defendants; District Council 37 Health and Security Plan, on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. Medi-Span, a division of Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc., Defendant 2009-03-17
Darlene MANSON, Deborah and Keith Nicholas, and Germano DePina, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated v. GMAC MORTGAGE, LLC, Avelo Mortgage, LLC, and U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee for Structured Asset Securities Corporation Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates Series 2006-EQ, on behalf of themselves and as representatives for all similarly situated, and Harmon Law Offices, P.C. and Ablitt Law Offices, P.C 2009-03-18
AMERICAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC. and Laserscope, Plaintiffs v. BIOLITEC, INC., Defendant 2009-03-20
Gloria O. SALCEDO, on her own behalf and as mother and next of friend of A.S., and as mother and next of friend of J.S., Plaintiffs, v. TOWN OF DUDLEY, Steven Wojnar, James Hutchinson, Anthony DiDonato, David Carpenter, Dean Poplawski, Paul Ceppetelli, and Other as Yet Unnamed Officers of the Dudley Police Department, individually and in their official capacities as Chief of Police and police officers of the Town of Dudley, Defendants 2009-03-20
Hilda SOLIS, Secretary of the United States Department of Labor, Plaintiff, v. PLAN BENEFIT SERVICES, INC., Defendant 2009-03-20
UNITED STATES of America ex. rel. Jacqueline Kay POTEET and John Doe v. Lawrence G. LENKE, M.D., et al. 2009-03-20
Inar RAGNAR, Plaintiff, v. Mary MORRISSEY, Ed Shannon, Department of Transitional Assistance, Julia E. Kehor, Brian Mullholand and Koren Anderson, Defendants 2009-03-23
Carlos PARRA, Plaintiff v. FOUR SEASONS HOTEL, Defendant 2009-03-23
Sally WIESMAN, Plaintiff, v. Robert HILL, Bob Pacetti, Roger Thuot, and the Fitchburg Housing Authority, Defendants 2009-03-24
UNITED STATES of America, ex rel. Patrick J. LOUGHREN, Plaintiff, v. UNUMPROVIDENT CORP., et al., Defendants 2009-03-24
Kevin M. LOUGHMAN, Petitioner, v. Steven OBRIEN, Respondent 2009-03-25
John C. STANTON, Plaintiff, v. LIGHTHOUSE FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC., and Thomas S. Drunsic, Defendants 2009-03-25
Alberto TORRES, Petitioner v. Kathleen M. DENNEHY, Commissioner of Massachusetts Department of Corrections, Respondent 2009-03-26
In re SMITH & WESSON HOLDING CORP. SEC. LITIG 2009-03-26
AMERICAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC. and Laserscope, Inc., Plaintiffs v. BIOLITEC, INC., et al., Defendants 2009-03-26
HEARTS ON FIRE COMPANY, LLC, Plaintiff, v. BLUE NILE, INC., Defendant 2009-03-27
In re Alexander V. SHERMAN, Appellant, v. Igor POTAPOV, et al., Appellees 2009-03-30
Andrew GODDARD, Plaintiff, v. William J. KELLEY, Daniel Humphreys, and Thomas Manning, Defendants 2009-03-31
Hiram GATHURU, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. CREDIT CONTROL SERVICES, INC., d/b/a Credit Collection Services, Defendant 2009-03-31
PEABODY ESSEX MUSEUM, INC., Plaintiff, v. UNITED STATES FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant/Third-Party Plaintiff, v. Century Indemnity Company, Third-Party Defendant 2009-03-31
Jason CLEMENTS, Petitioner, v. Howard W. CLARKE, Respondent 2009-03-31
UNITED STATES of America v. Andre ELLIS, Defendant 2009-03-31
UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff, v. $572,204 IN UNITED STATES CURRENCY, MORE OR LESS, Defendant 2009-03-31
Paul BERGERON, Individually and on behalf of the P. Bergeron Nominee Trust v. RIDGEWOOD SECURITIES CORP., et al. 2009-03-31
Duane WILSON, Plaintiff v. The EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, Defendant 2009-04-01
Willie ELLERBEE, Plaintiff v. GAMESTOP, INC., Defendant 2009-04-02
Samuel Bartley STEELE, Bart Steele Publishing and Steele Recordz, Plaintiffs, v. TURNER BROADCASTING SYSTEM, INC., Time Warner Corporation, Jon Bongiovi (individually and d/b/a Bon Jovi Publishing), Richard Sambora (individually and d/b/a Aggressive Music), William Falcone (individually and d/b/a Pretty Blue Songs), Fox Broadcasting Company, Major League Baseball Properties, A & E Television Networks, AEG Live, Mark Shimmel Music, Vector 2 LLC, Universal Music Publishing, Universal Polygram International Publishing, Sony ATV Tunes, Boston Red Sox and Kobalt Music Publishing America, Inc., Defendants 2009-04-03
Christopher SMITH, Plaintiff, v. JEFFERSON PILOT FINANCIAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant 2009-04-08
Jean C. ALLARD, Plaintiff, v. CITIZENS BANK and Dennis Wyatt, Defendants 2009-04-09
Commonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS by its DIVISION OF MARINE FISHERIES, and State of New Hampshire, by its Fish & Game Department, Division of Marine Fisheries, Plaintiffs v. Carlos M. GUTIERREZ, in his official capacity as Secretary of Commerce of the United States, et al., Defendants 2009-04-10
In re GRAND JURY MATTER 2009-04-10
Carl DREW, Petitioner, v. SUPERINTENDENT, MCI-SHIRLEY, Respondent 2009-04-10
In re Saris KAVLAKIAN 2009-04-13
The REAL ESTATE BAR ASSOCIATION FOR MASSACHUSETTS, INC., Plaintiff, v. NATIONAL REAL ESTATE INFORMATION SERVICES and National Real Estate Information Services, Inc., Defendants 2009-04-13
In re HIGH VOLTAGE ENGINEERING CORPORATION, et al. 2009-04-14
Commonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS by its DIVISION OF MARINE FISHERIES, and State of New Hampshire, by its Fish & Game Department, Division of Marine Fisheries, Plaintiffs v. Carlos M. GUTIERREZ, in his official capacity as Secretary of Commerce of the United States, et al., Defendants 2009-04-14
UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff, v. PAUL REVERE TRANSPORTATION, LLC, Defendant 2009-04-14
Soeun KIM, Plaintiff v. Beverly VEGLAS, Kathleen Dennehy, Martin A. Magnusson, Jeffrey Merrill, Carl McHatten, Jane DePalma, Jackie Weddle, John Marshall, Abbe Nelligan, Anne Marie Aucoin, Tom Neville, Nelson Riley, and John Doe Starbird, Defendants 2009-04-16
UNITED STATES of America v. Angel CAMACHO 2009-04-16
In re WOLVERINE, PROCTOR & SCHWARTZ, LLC, Debtor. Lynne F. Riley, Chapter 7 Trustee of Wolverine, Proctor & Schwartz, LLC, Plaintiff v. Wolverine, Proctor & Schwartz, Ltd., Deepak S. Kulkarni, Mark A. Brown, Foley & Lardner LLP, and Remedial Capital, LLC, Defendants 2009-04-17
Rocco LAUDANO, Plaintiff v. 214 SOUTH STREET CORPORATION, INC. and James Martorilli and Marla Martorilli, Defendants 2009-04-17
Yong LI, Plaintiff, v. Dr. Julia M. READE, Defendant 2009-04-17
CROSS ROADS R.V. CENTER, INC., Plaintiff, v. TEXTRON FINANCIAL CORP., Defendant 2009-04-22
In re GRAND JURY 2009-04-23
UNITED AIR LINES, INC., Plaintiff, v. Joshua Gregory ALLEN a/k/a Joshua Gregory a/k/a Allen Gregory agent of Gregory Joshua a/k/a Joshua Allen and Omar Safar Halabi a/k/a Omar Safar, Defendants 2009-04-24
Brian BENOIT, et al., Plaintiffs v. TRI-WIRE ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS, INC., Defendant 2009-04-24
AKAMAI TECHNOLOGIES, INC., et al. v. LIMELIGHT NETWORKS, INC. 2009-04-24
UNITED STATES of America v. Darwin JONES, Defendant 2009-04-27
Douglas A. ABDELNOUR, Jr., Plaintiff, v. BASSETT CUSTOM BOATWORKS, INC., W. Dana Bassett, Ian OConnell and J & J Marine Fabricating, Inc., Defendants 2009-04-27
Pasquale BARONE v. UNITED STATES of America; Vincent Ferrara v. United States of America 2009-04-28
CRISP HUMAN CAPITAL LIMITED, Plaintiff, v. AUTHORIA INC., Defendant 2009-04-28
Seva BRODSKY, Plaintiff, v. NEW ENGLAND SCHOOL OF LAW, Defendant 2009-04-29
Robert WADE, Plaintiff, v. Bernard F. BRADY, Thomas F. Reilly, and Timothy J. Cruz, Defendants 2009-04-30
Delshaune FLIPP, Plaintiff, v. TOWN OF ROCKLAND, Defendant 2009-04-30
Glory N. NNA, Administratrix of the Estate of Hillary Obioma Nna, Michael P. Mason, Jory S. Mason, and Peter W. Lee, Plaintiffs, v. AMERICAN STANDARD, INC., Defendant 2009-05-01
Barbara CIRCIELLO v. Louis ALFANO, Jr., M.D. and Hallmark Health Systems, Inc. 2009-05-04
UNITED STATES of America v. Brima WURIE 2009-05-04
Franklin D. HOLDREN, et al., Plaintiffs, v. BUFFALO PUMPS, INC., et al., Defendants 2009-05-04
In re NEURONTIN MARKETING, SALES PRACTICES, AND PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION 2009-05-05
Robert CRANSHAW, Plaintiff, v. CUMBERLAND FARMS, INC. and L.H.B. Enterprises, Inc., Defendants 2009-05-05
ATLANTIC RESEARCH MARKETING SYSTEMS, INC., Plaintiff, v. Stephen P. TROY, Jr., and Troy Industries, Inc., Defendants 2009-05-05
Maria C. KARLIS, Movant, v. United States SECURITIES and EXCHANGE COMMISSION, Respondent 2009-05-08
VERMONT MUTUAL INSURANCE CO., Plaintiff, v. Mary E. PETIT and Frank Petit, Trustees of 93A Hillside Street Nominee Trust, et al., Defendants 2009-05-11
Anastasia KUCHARSKI, Plaintiff, v. TRIBECA LENDING CORPORATION and Carteret Mortgage Corporation, Defendants 2009-05-12
In re NEURONTIN MARKETING, SALES PRACTICES AND PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION 2009-05-13
The SOUTHERN NEW ENGLAND TELEPHONE COMPANY, Plaintiff, v. GLOBAL NAPS, INC., Global Naps New Hampshire, Inc., Global Naps Networks, Inc., Global Naps Realty, Inc. and Ferrous Miner Holdings, Ltd., Defendants. Convergent Networks, Inc. and Frank T. Gangi, Reach and Apply Defendants 2009-05-14
BARLETTA HEAVY DIVISION, INC., Plaintiff, v. ERIE INTERSTATE CONTRACTORS, INC., Phoenix Development & Construction, Inc., Gregory Zafirakis, Steven Moutsastos, Steven Zafirakis and Erie Painting & Maintenance, Inc., Defendants 2009-05-15
Eric COUTURE, Petitioner, v. UNITED STATES of America, Respondent 2009-05-15
Gregory P. MORSON v. KREINDLER & KREINDLER, LLP 2009-05-15
John CREEDEN, Plaintiff, v. Perry SANIEOFF, Harold Simansky and Linda Simansky, Defendants 2009-05-15
UNITED STATES of America v. Darwin JONES, Defendant 2009-05-18